| |
July/August 1999
A three-step strategy for helping students delve deeper into texts
By Vicki A. Jacobs
You want me to teach reading?
But I'm a content teacher.
I don't have time to stop and
teach reading. Besides, I wouldn't
even know how to begin.
These are typical concerns of secondary teachers when asked to take more responsibility for their students' reading. One reason for their concern may be confusion about what secondary reading is.
Simply put, if reading through grades 3 or 4 is about learning to read-acquiring the skills needed to decode the written word automatically and fluently-then reading from about grade 4 on is about using those skills to comprehend what is written-that is, using reading to learn. Texts used in subject areas often employ language, syntax, vocabulary, and concepts that are specific to a particular field of study. Merely assigning reading does not help students learn how to tangle with these specialized texts to construct meaning: teachers must help prepare students for and guide them through the texts so that they will learn from them most effectively.
Pre-Reading
To avoid feeling that they have to stop teaching content in order to teach reading, secondary teachers might think of reading as a comprehension or understanding process that involves three stages. (These stages are derived from a model of learning called "schema theory.") The first stage is called pre-reading. One of the purposes of pre-reading is to acknowledge the different contexts, experiences, biases, and background knowledge (often called the "given") of students that will influence how they read and learn from a text (the "new"). By knowing what students bring to their reading, teachers can provide them with bridges, or scaffolds, between the given and the new-clarifying unfamiliar vocabulary and concepts, and offering other necessary information in the process. Pre-reading activities also promote students' engagement and interest by providing them with means to preview and anticipate the text. Such preparatory activity is critical for comprehension to occur.
For example, a 9th-grade social studies class may be planning to read about Moscow as an introduction to a unit on Russia. Depending on the purpose of the reading (and it is important to be explicit to students about purposes), the teacher might have students brainstorm individually about what they already know about a national capital that is more familiar to them: Washington, DC. Most likely, the brainstorm will spark both common associations (such as the president, the Capitol, cherry blossoms, or Arlington National Cemetery), as well as less common associations certain students might have because of their own knowledge and experience (say, the Holocaust Museum, or an anecdote about a visit to Washington, DC). The class could then compile and share their brainstorms, which the teacher can use to help the students grasp particular concepts or vocabulary that will be important to understanding the text.
The class might then organize their brainstorms into categories (such as monuments, government buildings, a tourist's view of the city), or into webs, outlines, or clusters-graphic organizers that visually illustrate the relationships among vocabulary or concepts. The teacher could then divide the class into small groups and assign each group a category from the brainstorm, asking them to use the Washington, DC, examples as a way to think about Moscow. For example, a group that is assigned "a tourist's view of the city" might consider whether there are gardens in Moscow that equal the beauty of cherry blossoms or whether there is a national cemetery near Moscow as there is near Washington, DC. They might also consider the monuments or government buildings that a tourist would be interested in seeing. As a result, the students build on the knowledge they bring to a text while beginning to anticipate and pose questions about that text.
In addition to brainstorming and graphically organizing information, teachers can also instruct students to ask and answer questions before reading. These questions, which can be supplied by the teacher or developed by students through directed writing or interactive discussion, might include, "What do I already know and what do I need to know before reading?" and "What do I think this passage will be about, given the headings, graphs, or pictures?" Teachers can also make use of cloze-that is, deleting important words or concepts from a passage and having students guess or choose the word that would best fit the blank. Pre-reading activity requires considerable time, but that time is a wise and critical investment, for it prepares students to actively engage with the text.
Guided Reading
The second stage of the reading process is called guided reading. During this stage, students need structured means to integrate the knowledge and information that they bring to the text with the "new" that is provided by the text. Guided-reading activities should engage students in probing the text beyond its literal meaning for deeper understanding. They should include multiple points of view, which is a requirement of higher stages of reading. Students should have the opportunity to revise their preliminary questions, search for tentative answers, gather, organize, analyze, and synthesize evidence, and begin to make generalizations or assertions about their new understanding.
A simple way to lead students beyond surface understanding is to reword the factual questions that texts characteristically provide at the end of a chapter into questions that ask "how" or "why." Such questions ask students not only to locate information, but also to apply that information in some substantive way. For example, a social studies text might ask, "What three rivers that flow through Russia are connected by canals?" Only surface comprehension is required for students to find and copy the answer from the text (the Don, Dneiper, and Volga Rivers). In contrast, a guided-reading question, such as "How would Russia's transportation and trade be affected if there were no canals to link the Don, Dneiper, and Volga rivers?" requires students to consider how facts from the text inform each other and help answer the question. Other common guided-reading activities include reader-response journals and study guides.
Post-Reading
Stage three of the secondary reading process is called post-reading. During this stage, teachers give students ways to articulate their understanding of what they have read, and then to test its validity, apply it to a novel situation, or argue it against an opposing assertion. For example, students might be asked to discuss how the United States and Russia are similar and different, given one aspect of Russian culture that they have studied (e.g., the people, geography, industry, or transportation). They then might be asked to argue what impact these similarities and differences might have when Russia and the United States need to come to some agreement of international consequence, such as the war in Kosovo.
By engaging students in pre-, guided-, and post-reading activities, teachers not only support students' understanding of content, but also provide them with opportunities to hone their comprehension, vocabulary, and study skills without interrupting content learning. Teachers should make decisions about how they will use such activities, depending on their purposes for teaching, the difficulty of the text, and how well their students can read the text. Most teachers already employ many of the principles and practices associated with the reading process. However, by becoming more aware of how they use them and to what end, teachers can become more confident about whether students comprehend both the word and the spirit of their texts.
Vicki A. Jacobs is a lecturer on education and associate director of Teacher Education Programs at the Harvard Graduate School of Education. This article draws from her book, Secondary Reading and Writing: Issues and Opportunities, which will be published by Brookline Books later this year.
For Further Information
J. Chall. Stages of Reading Development. New York: McGraw-Hill, 1983.
D.W. Moore, J.E. Readence, and R.J. Rickelman. Prereading Activities for Content Area Reading and Learning (2nd ed.). Newark, DE: International Reading Association, 1989.
B.D. Roe, B.D. Stoodt, and P.C. Burns. Secondary School Reading Instruction: The Content Areas (6th ed.). Boston, MA: Houghton Mifflin, 1998.
|
|